A Philosophical Critique of Empirical Arguments for - download pdf or read online

By Michael Sudduth

ISBN-10: 1137440945

ISBN-13: 9781137440945

ISBN-10: 1349552550

ISBN-13: 9781349552559

Sudduth presents a severe exploration of classical empirical arguments for survival arguments that purport to teach that information gathered from ostensibly paranormal phenomena represent stable facts for the survival of the self after dying. using the conceptual instruments of formal epistemology, he argues that classical arguments are unsuccessful.

Show description

Read Online or Download A Philosophical Critique of Empirical Arguments for Postmortem Survival PDF

Best occult & paranormal books

Read e-book online Inside the Spaceships PDF

Contained in the house Ships is a 1955 revised variation, moment printing, of the 1953 unique vintage. released by means of the George Adamski starting place, the publication is split into elements 1 and a couple of, with a foreword to half via Desmond Leslie. half 1 is George Adamsky's section of the ebook "Flying Saucers Have Landed," that is co-authored with Desmond Leslie.

New PDF release: The Sacred Symbols of Mu

Absolutely illustrated. in keeping with Churchward, Mu was once a misplaced continent within the Pacific Ocean, which was once destroyed in an international cataclysm tens of hundreds of thousands of years in the past; Mu used to be the unique domestic of mankind, and all next civilizations descended from it. The Pacific islands and their population are meant to be the final survivors of this primordial motherland.

Read e-book online The Cambridge History of Magic and Witchcraft in the West: PDF

This ebook provides twenty chapters through specialists of their fields, supplying a radical and interdisciplinary evaluation of the idea and perform of magic within the West. Its chronological scope extends from the traditional close to East to twenty-first-century North the USA; its items of study variety from Persian curse capsules to U.

Extra resources for A Philosophical Critique of Empirical Arguments for Postmortem Survival

Example text

This would also be important for models of personal survival since personal survival requires that a postmortem person be numerically identical to some formerly living person, not merely that a survivor be some postmortem human person or other. Survivalists typically introduce some particular criterion of personal identity to explicate the idea of personal survival, but there are three considerations that plausibly reinforce and strengthen the idea of psychological survival. First, as noted above, many people assume that their identity is constituted by or essentially tied to their psychological life – the “psychological criterion” of identity, as it is called, historically associated with John Locke.

Jones’ body is Mr. Jones himself; or, in the language of philosophers, 26 A Philosophical Critique of Empirical Arguments what survives the death of Mr. Jones’ body is an individual who is numerically identical with Mr. Jones” (Moore 1981: 9). So personal survival means I – this individual self – will survive death. 1 Personal identity: soul survival vs. embodied survival To speak of personal survival, of course, entails that whatever properties are essential to persons in general will survive death.

J. Ducasse once observed: so long as one does not know just what one means by the phrase “the personality’s survival after death,” one cannot tell what kinds of observable facts would or would not constitute evidence of such survival ... The variety of possibilities concerning “the human personality’s survival after death” will, it is hoped, have made evident how imperative is the need to state which particular one of those possibilities is that whose reality one is seeking to test. (Ducasse 1957: 30, 35) I agree with Ducasse here, so in this chapter I lay a conceptual foundation for the project to be undertaken in subsequent chapters.

Download PDF sample

A Philosophical Critique of Empirical Arguments for Postmortem Survival by Michael Sudduth


by Steven
4.0

Rated 4.56 of 5 – based on 12 votes